I ask Bethany Joy Lenz when she reached the point of no return. "Point of no return... 'The Phantom of the Opera' is playing ...

Bethany Joy Lenz is opening up about her experience being ... explaining that the group initially involved singing, worshipping and having conversations about God and life’s meaning.

Bethany Joy Lenz is paying tribute to a longtime friend ... all set to a recording of Teal singing "'Sunday Train,' Noah's big solo," in the show. "Now at 35, he’s taken another train.

Singer Tyler Hilton, who had a recurring role on the teen drama, revealed this week he had tried to date co-star Bethany Joy Lenz, but her cult got in the way. "We were getting closer and closer ...